What Is a Proforma Invoice vs Commercial Invoice, Both Made From One Shipment

Proforma vs commercial invoice: what each one does, the checklist and common mistakes, and why making both from the same shipment keeps the quote, the final invoice and the shipment’s profit in line.

BY Tijara Editorial Team· REVIEWED BY Tijara Trade Operations Team· PUBLISHED May 11, 2026· UPDATED Nov 7, 2026· 2 min read

Quick answer

Compliance becomes predictable when documents and declarations are driven by structured data: stable party master, item master with HS codes, locked Incoterms/place, and a pre-filing validation checklist.

The proforma invoice quotes the shipment before the sale is final. The commercial invoice bills it once the goods ship. When both are made from the same shipment record, the items, quantities and prices match, and the price you quoted is the one you measure the shipment's profit against.

Step-by-step checklist

  1. Create a checklist and assign owners for each control point.
  2. Standardize master data (parties, items, HS codes, Incoterms/place).
  3. Generate documents from the shipment record to avoid mismatches.
  4. Track deadlines/approvals as a timeline, not inbox threads.
  5. Reconcile actual costs and outcomes back to the shipment.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Issuing documents before item/party master data is finalized.
  • Using inconsistent product descriptions across invoice, packing list, and transport documents.
  • Treating HS code as a one-time task instead of a controlled change.
  • Losing version control (multiple PDFs floating around the team).
  • Reconciling costs only at month-end instead of per shipment.

A simple operating model (strict, but practical)

Control pointWhat to captureWhy it prevents rework
Item masterSKU description + HS code + UOMKeeps invoice/PL/declaration consistent
TermsIncoterm + named place + payment termsAligns responsibilities and expectations
DocumentsOne current PDF version per documentPrevents mismatched copies in circulation
Cost ledgerFreight, duty/tax, clearance, deliveryMakes landed cost and margin explainable

How Tijara helps

In Tijara both invoices are made from the shipment. Each shipment holds its items, costs, documents, invoices, LC, containers and payments. The proforma and the commercial invoice take their items and terms from that record and go to the buyer as a PDF on WhatsApp. With costs on the same shipment, Tijara works out its landed cost, profit and margin.

Tijara works alongside Tally or Zoho for the books. It is not an accounting system.

FAQ

Questions, answered

Sources

  1. [1] DGFT: Importer-Exporter Code (IEC) overview
    DGFT, Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government of India • Accessed: 2026-05-11
  2. [2] World Customs Organization - What is the Harmonized System (HS)?
    World Customs Organization • Accessed: 2026-05-11
  3. [3] UAE Government Portal: Customs duty rates
    UAE Government • Accessed: 2026-05-11
  4. [4] Incoterms 2020
    International Chamber of Commerce • Accessed: 2026-05-11

Related resources

Glossary terms

GET STARTED

See what every shipment really made

Keep each shipment's items, costs, documents and payments in one record. Tijara works out its landed cost and profit, and makes the invoices from it.